Ace Attorney is one of my favorite game series of all time. There is just something so satisfying about investigating, building up an evidence portfolio and then catching the bad guy in a courtroom battle. Of course, this is all supported by most of AA's character's being really fun and interesting and the cases being generally mysterious until the very end, with few exceptions. The gameplay loop of AA games flows smoothly and for a long time I wanted more games out there that do what AA does. I know there are a few AA clones (for lack of a better term) out there, but Tyrion Cuthbert is the first one I ever played. It works in the exact same way - gather evidence at crime scenes with Tyrion, the protagonist, and sidekick Celeste, and then head into the courtroom to cross-examine witnesses, present evidence and figure out whodunnit. It's an exact clone in most respects, with even the credits scene doing exactly what the AA games do (with the game's characters showing up to give a short epilogue speech). Well, I suppose with how unique AA's gameplay is, it stands to reason that any clone would follow the formula almost exactly, so I'm not faulting the game for that. Still, Tyrion Cuthbert has a few of it's own gimmicks, such as phrases that need to be created by choosing from sentence fragments, winning arguments by appealing to emotions and presenting evidence, or reading minds with the protagonists' convenient ability "Eye Of Horus". Since Tyrion Cuthbert also plays in a world of magic, it adds another interesting element - not only is there a deep rift between the nobles, mages and the commonfolk in this world, you also have "Spells" as an additional evidence tab that can be presented in cases. It gives the entire game an interesting fantasy magic angle that sets it apart slightly from the more grounded AA series (well, at least until the later games). I think TC is doing an admirable job as an AA clone overall, with most cases being somewhat interesting, but there are quite a few QOL and quality issues. I don't mind it feeling "cheaper" than AA, as this is a small team we're talking about and not Capcom, but here are some of my issues in no particular order: [*] The general art and soundtrack is decent, but especially the soundtrack feels a bit flat to me, with most tracks leaving no particular impression and the cross examination soundtrack being especially repetitive given how often you hear it. The character art itself lacks a bit of personality - again, this isn't Capcom of course, but AA is the only real comparison I can draw, so I will do it. I also miss character breakdowns at the end of a trial which aren't really present here, which is surprising given how much of this game is a direct clone. [*] The general storytelling of this game is a bit confusing; it does a good enough job at slowly introducing you to the world and it's stakes, but it gets out of hand a bit especially in the last two cases where you are overwhelmed with mountains of new lore, circumstances and reveals out of nowhere in what is already a relatively short-ish game. It ends in a cliffhanger for a second part which I hope will come and flesh out some of the issues. [*] QOL is probably my biggest issue. The game runs well on Steamdeck, but somehow drains a lot more battery than it should. The controls on Steamdeck are also quite bad as the game has no controller support (which, again, I feel like it should have). A custom layout is necessary to play it halfway decent on the deck, but even then you'll be doing a lot of moving a mouse around to click on things instead of just being able to use a stick to go from option to option. Another QOL problem is the evidence sorting, which is sorted by when you received the evidence. That may make sense at first, but especially in Cases 4 and 5 it's hard to keep an overview of what evidence really relates to what, especially as most are just icons of faces. Speaking of evidence, unlike in AA where every piece of evidence you find matters, half of the evidence in some of the cases in this game is never used for anything, which I found very frustrating. At least you can't really "lose" in this game as there is no healthbar (except in the overall rather easy arguments), so you can just spam evidence until you find the piece that is correct - which, especially in the very confusing Case 5, was sometimes my only option. It's also annoying when you receive a spell compendium of someone with all their spells - like in the last case, where you have 20+ spells listed at once and only three (I believe) are used as evidence [*] The characters aren't nearly as interesting as I would expect, which is mostly a writing issue. Most of the characters are fairly one-dimensional, and even the protagonist and sidekick are very boring overall, even including some of the later story beats, and their inevitable romance doesn't really fit into the game imo. The protagonist's ability is also a bit overpowered for a game focused so much on logic and evidence (being able to read minds, that is), though this is being picked up by the story at some point and dealt with somewhat appropriately, but it still feels a bit weird in a game like this. Now that seems like a lot of criticism - that being said, while I kind of was mixed about the game as I was playing it and went back and forth between recommended and not recommended, I do end up recommending it because it did a decent job building up a whole new universe that will hopefully be fleshed out more with a second game. The cases are generally entertaining, though most of them are somewhat unsurprising as the game constantly makes it obvious who committed what, which hurt the mystery a bit. There were only a few surprises as the game went on but they helped shake up things a bit at least. And even though, as mentioned, most characters feel a bit flat, I did end up liking a few of them, so the game managed to do that at least! I commend the effort that was put into a whole game like this with 5 cases, though most of them are shorter than your typical AA case. In most respects, it feels like AA lite with a few additional issues that may or may not be a dealbreaker for you. Definitely do not pay the full price for this, but on a sale of 50% or more, I would recommend checking it out if you really, really love Ace Attorney and can deal with the mentioned issues.
Expand the review