Witch on the holy night/Mahoyo is a visual novel made by Type-Moon. Type-Moon are at this point extreme veterans when it comes to making high budget visual novels, making classics like Fate/Stay night and Tsukihime. Its asking price may seem high for a game with no gameplay (There are no choices during the story and its pretty much just reading non stop), but that price very quickly makes sense as you dive into the incredible story of Mahoyo. Lets get into what makes this such a good visual novel. I think the biggest crowning achievement this visual novel manages to pull off is its incredible presentation and writing. Its a visual novel with a fairly low scope compared to some of type-moons previous work. There are no real world ending confrontations, almost all conflicts are personal. As a result the writing and the presentation have to do a lot of work to still make you feel the impact of these scenes. And it does so incredibly well. So many locations are drawn with detail, scenes switch up rapidly and make excellent use of cinematography, all the music and voice acting sounds great and sticks with you. Back that up with beautiful art and you get a really well made visual novel. Some of the action scenes made me forget I am reading a novel, the writing would flow so perfectly with the presentation that my own head narration felt like a part of the story. They are scenes that are going to stick with me for a long time, a movie adaptation has been announced 3 years ago, and its honestly hard to imagine how a proper animation adaptation could top what has been offered here. Speaking of story. Type-moon has never been scared of making slower scenes, if they want you to read a 1 hour long optional essay surrounding the extinction of pigeons then you will read and enjoy it. Thats the level of trust the developers have in you as the reader, the scenes are so different from what you would usually read about. But through excellent execution and touching on genuinely interesting topics the story manages to consistently grab you. There are scenes that are purely characters talking to each other, and you can feel the weight that the conversation has through the intonation of the voice, the detailed write ups on the scenery, the scene composition. The main trio of characters ends up being some of my favorites in any visual novel, they clearly have a lot of faults as people, but those faults are explored and in the end make you like them for what they do well and how they handle those faults. Its always a joy to explore the characters and the story touches on some really difficult topics like adapting to completely new environments or dealing with responsibility that are forced on you. There are a lot of moments in the story that allowed me to reflect on my own position in life and appreciate it more. That being said there are things that the visual novel doesn't always do that well. The writing at times can be a bit too slow even for me. The game starts with an incredibly gripping intro using really cool visual styles. Right after that it gets into the introduction of characters. Then it gets into more introductions. Many hours are spent just talking about locations or slice of life scenes. There are so many of those scenes that just end up not feeling very meaningful because the side cast isn't very fleshed out. A lot of time is spent with the main trio, but most other characters are uncharacteristically not explored a lot. Another minor complaint I have is the translation work, there were a good amount of typos and certain translations that made me scratch my head compared to what was being said by the voice actors, its impossible to have a perfect localisation, its not bad, but I at times wish it was just a bit better. All of this adds onto my biggest complaint which might as well be a compliment. The story does not feel complete. This was meant to be a trilogy. But after more then 10 years there is still no mention of part 2 coming out. You can really feel it in the way the story ends and the way this whole story writes about its characters. It all feels like its supposed to be a prologue or an introduction to a much bigger plot. So when those credits rolled around the only thought I could muster was: ''Wait, thats it?''. It leaves you with so many questions around the characters, the story and some of the lore that has been built up. Its the hallmark of a great visual novel, having me read for this long and still making me want more. But at the same time it does feel very disappointing. As for newcomers to type-moon or visual novels in general. This is a fantastic entry point. Type-Moon loves using confusing terms or creating really weird situations. But this is easily the most accessible visual novel they have made. You need 0 knowledge to enjoy it, in fact you will probably enjoy certain parts more because of it. The visual novel loves explaining concepts that are common in type-moon, but if you for example already know what the difference between magic and magecraft is, then those scenes might end up feeling more dull and repetitive. The game in general doesn't always dive in depth into its lore. Which makes it an excellent entry point. There are certain scenes that maybe don't hit as hard if you are a new comer, but those are bonuses and don't really ruin the story or make it feel worse. At the end of the night, we are left with a visual novel that is absolutely incredible. Its strong story keeps you wanting for more. Its main cast is memorable and fun. The cinematography and presentation is top tier for the genre. For those who are big type-moon fans, this story will absolutely sate your appetite, there are long awaited scenes here that will make the lore nerd inside you happy and that has a quality that holds itself up to some of their greatest work like Lostbelt 6, Heavens feel or Kara no Kyoukais bridge scene. I give Witch on the holy night my highest recommendation if you are willing to sit through a visual novel, definitely take the time to read some of the optional content that unlocks as you read through the main story, a lot of it is really good.
Expand the review