The short version: - Give it a try at a discount. - This second game more or less meets the expectations I had of the first, which is a positive. - Completionists (or otherwise) are advised to go into the game with some patience due to the absence of some commonplace QoL features and polish. "Metroidvania" enthusiasts may experience friction here if viewing this game through that genre's lens (hence the quotation marks). - People skipping the first game to play this need not worry about story or missing context. The long(er) version: I was ambivalent toward the first Gal Guardians title, and I'm ambivalent about this one. The main difference is that I'm leaning mildly positive this time despite the quality between both games landing on the same plane, crudely speaking. I mentioned missing QoL features and some missing polish earlier, so I'll get that out the way: 1) Progression tracking (a lack of number-based displays for chests discovered/opened, weapon types gained, Demonglyphs acquired, etc.) 2) Button commands for tutorials (Patched) 3) Boss scripting (for one boss in particular) 4) A sense of reward for exploration and/or creative traversal 5) An answer behind the hidden friction between bone-collecting and increased survival 6) A slightly larger soundtrack 7) Balance between characters Recent patches have addressed the second point. I'll cover the bullet points in descending order. The lower they are down the list, the less they matter. Progression tracking is left to you, and the more you collect, the harder that'll become. To clarify, the map has clearly defined indicators for the locations of chests, for example, but if you want to know if you have 60 out of 125 chests, you'll find no such info. On the bright side, there is no achievement for discovering and opening all chests. The negative side, for completionists at least, is that your sole resource--the map--can only offer you vague truths. You can't necessarily trust that you've discovered and opened every chest; you can only account for the chests which have appeared as an icon on your map. These icons don't appear unless you get within reasonable proximity of a chest, a few of which require frankly abstract solutions to even discover, let alone reach. I'm more than willing to excuse the lack of tracking for Demonglyphs, as you can determine their number by counting the stone doors, which are not many nor hidden. Overall, the lack of numbers for tracking makes troubleshooting take a lot longer than it otherwise would, especially if you reach a point of not knowing where to go or how to get there. Sometimes, just having a number is enough of a clue for how to set your priorities, whether that's looking for bones, chests, Demonglyphs, or something else. For the boss-scripting part, I refer to the named boss in the desert. There's an attack which places spiked balls onto the ground in randomized locations. To cut the explanation short, those hazards can linger for over a minute, and depending on how the boss' follow-up attacks play out, the overlap can force you to take damage from the old hazards or the new attack(s). As an Inti Creates fan and former Gunvolt/Mega Man Zero super-enthusiast, this is unsightly coming from Inti Creates. For decades, they specialized in creating attack patterns that appear to be "checkmate" situations but have a skillful solution to weave through them unscathed. No matter how difficult a boss was designed to be, the consequence of taking damage was reserved purely for those who either fell short of the skill demand or have yet to figure out a solution to evade. I never expected this desert boss to impose even one scenario where the object of avoiding damage relied this much on luck. It's just enough that I believe this was not intentional, especially since only this one boss has that problem and all others before and after that do not. For the sense of reward point, this is consistently belittled by chests awarding you trash. The very last chest I discovered in my playthrough contained a Demonglyph. The very last. I can't tell you how many chests I had to open, just praying it wouldn't contain a trash sub weapon that was outclassed by average enemy drops, or money which I had no use for, or consumables which I never used once. Even some of the most out-of-the-way chests can contain something with no practical or even intangible (sense of completion) value. In that sense, it feels more along the lines of checking off boxes sans a true sense of progression. The sense of exploration is there, but your sense of progression relies pretty heavily on bones or things which lead to the possibility of bones, since these are used to unlock abilities and powers essential to completing the story. On the flip side, now that I've completed a playthrough and now know what I'm doing, I would almost certainly enjoy my second playthrough more than my first by an order of magnitude, because I've come to terms with the fact that bones are the most high-value thing in the game. For the friction between bone-collecting and survival, there are several points in the game where bosses can kill you so convincingly (usually due to your damage being low, not their damage being high), it forces you to rethink if your level is too low for the challenge. This is not a problem in itself, but when you combine this with the bone supply suddenly drying up in a given region (be it from chests or from enemies), it leaves you questioning where you're supposed to be in order to collect the amount of bones needed to survive. Not necessarily a negative, but I do think it stirs a bit of temporary confusion when bones go back and forth between seeming finite, then infinite, then back to finite. Again, this could all be avoided if the game tracked progression by telling you how many bones and chests exist in total, and how many you've gotten. For the last one, Masha's good enough that Kirika takes a backseat. Why? I don't know what to call it. Walk canceling? Masha has a standard combo for which you press the attack button thrice. It's powerful but not very good. Instead, hold forward and press attack only once, doing just the first strike of the combo. When that strike's animation ends, Masha runs due to you holding forward, which allows you to use the first whip strike again. Whip, walk, whip, walk, whip. Essentially, what you get is Masha's high damage at nearly the speed of Kirika's bullets. If your target is grounded, Masha is the better of the two and it's not even close. I wouldn't know how to address that. Lower Masha's HP? Give the first strike of her combo longer recovery to force people to commit to the full combo? Make the first strike a bit weaker? As it stands, there's no reason to use the combo because the damage from walk canceling is higher. There's also no reason to use Masha's backdash with this technique because the first whip strike of her combo is extremely fast (and rightfully so). It's fun to do, so I vote for leaving it as is. Outside of that, by all common metrics--story (and humor), gameplay mechanics, world/level design, art style, music, voice acting, replayability, exploration, overall length--this game has either met or slightly exceeded my expectations, albeit the bar was somewhat low. There are things a class above which I would recommend over this, whether you care about this genre or not; Shantae and the Pirate's Curse if you do, Ys ORIGIN if you don't (along with Felghana and Napishtim if you like Origin). If you want to kill time with Gal Guardians, this is a solid choice. If they make a third Gal Guardians game, I wouldn't say no. They did well enough with these two titles that I didn't regret my time with either of them, high marks from someone who generally doesn't care about this genre of game.