Games like Pony Island on Steam
For those who prefer not to search, lists of the most played, top deals and best free games like Pony Island are available at the bottom of the page.
Filters & Lists
When the Darkness comes
When the Darkness comes is a walking simulator whose glitchy and dark tale tries to illustrate the hardships of depression and anxiety through a variety of imaginary digital landscapes.
Giraffe Town
A giraffe born with slippery feet sets out to find love...
Saint Kotar: The Yellow Mask
Follow the fear of Benedek Dohnany and Nikolay Kalyakin and play the onset of a dark and chilling narrative adventure. Make decisions and affect the events that precede a macabre series of murders, allegedly related to devil worship and witchcraft.
Never Again
Never Again - Horror/first-person Quest. The main essence of the game is research locations and puzzles, plunging in the dramatic story of a little girl suffering from asthma.
Dead Secret
Dead Secret is a first-person horror mystery set in rural Kansas in 1965. A reclusive professor is dead and it’s up to you to crack the case before you become the next victim. Investigate the murder and explore the story Time Magazine called “captivating” and “deeply creepy” .
The Deer
"The Deer" is an educational interactive experience for children. You'll be an ancient Deer during the Pleistocene (Ice Age) epoch and you'll discover everything about this marvelous era. Unfortunately there were no T-Rex during this age since they were already extinct millions of years before.
Decay: The Mare
Sam is an addict who ends up in an institution named “Reaching Dreams”, hoping to kick his drug problem and sort out his miserable life. But during the first night, something goes horribly wrong and he gets stuck in an endless nightmare…
The Cat Lady
The Cat Lady follows Susan Ashworth, a lonely 40-year old on the verge of suicide. She has no family, no friends and no hope for a better future. One day she discovers that five strangers will come along and change everything...
Penumbra Overture
Penumbra: Overture is a first person survival horror game, emphasizing on survival and problem solving instead of mindless violence and gore.
Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk
A sequel to Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk. Dive into demented and bizarre world once again and help the girl become a little happier.
Doctor Who: The Lonely Assassins
Uncover the dark secrets of Wester Drumlins and confront a new evil in a thrilling found-phone mystery from the award-winning creators of Sara Is Missing and SIMULACRA.
Tsugunohi
One of the most terrifying J-horror games of all time is coming to Steam at long last. What's more, all you have to do is make the player walk to the left!? This collection includes the seven initial works of the popular Tsugunohi series, as well as an entirely new episode.
Cyber Manhunt
Cyber Manhunt is a story-oriented puzzle game focusing on big data, hacking, citizen privacy, and social workers. It focuses on social issues such as cyber violence and privacy breaches.
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a folk horror narrative-driven adventure. Explore the isolated moors of rural Victorian England as you uncover the mysteries of Hob's Barrow. The answers lie in the soil...
港詭實錄ParanormalHK
Paranormal HK is a first person horror game about Urban legends of Hong Kong, China. The story is about a crew of online supernatural channel“Beyond the Invisible” went to Kowloon Walled City to film a short movie for their latest episode and encountered something out of their expectations.
Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.7 Minagoroshi
Higurashi When They Cry is a sound novel. The music, backgrounds and characters work together to create a world that is the stage of a novel for the user to read. They laugh and cry and get angry. The user takes the point of view of the protagonist to experience the story.
STAY
Award-winning, innovative puzzle-adventure. By communicating through your PC, you must help a kidnapped man escape captivity - in real-time. While you sleep, he is alone. When you return to your PC he has hope. Your encouragement and advice will be the difference between his salvation or despair.
Break the Game
This game is about Kevin, He's been stuck in his gaf̶̨s̨fẃ̵̕ HEY, YOU, STAY AWA̸̧͘Y, IT'S ME KEVIN, THERE'S NO POINT, D҉Ò̷̕N̸̕͏'T-- Follow him in this adventurous and humor-filled story to ｄ̶̢͙̟̦̺̰̫̙̋̊͐̐͑͋̈́̕̕͝ ｄｉｅ
Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony
A new cast of 16 characters find themselves kidnapped and imprisoned in a school. Inside, some will kill, some will die, and some will be punished. Reimagine what you thought high-stakes, fast-paced investigation was as you investigate twisted murder cases and condemn your new friends to death.
Bear With Me - Episode One
Bear With Me is an episodic noir adventure game. Amber is trying to find her missing brother while being aided by her trusty teddy, Ted E. Bear.
Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair
Jabberwock Island—You and your classmates were ready for fun in the sun until Monokuma returned to restart his murderous game! Trapped in a kill-or-be-killed situation, your only hope rests in solving the island’s mysteries.Most played games like Pony Island on Steam
Take a look at the top games like Pony Island that are currently attracting the largest player bases on the Steam platform, as of May 01st 2025.
1. Undertale
Similarity 62% UNDERTALE! The RPG game where you don't have to destroy anyone. Undertale is a great soundtrack, story rich and choices matter game developed and published by tobyfox. Released on September 15th 2015 has received 267,059 reviews of which 258,340 were positive and 8,719 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game has hit the top spot as the #1 most played game like Pony Island, thanks to its 1,884 peak concurrent players over the last day.
9.6
258,340
8,719
1,884
players
2. Buckshot Roulette
Similarity 51% Play Russian roulette with a 12-gauge shotgun. Four enter. One leaves. Roll the dice with your life. Good luck! Buckshot Roulette is a multiplayer, dark and gambling game developed by Mike Klubnika and published by CRITICAL REFLEX. Released on April 04th 2024 has received 92,496 reviews of which 88,870 were positive and 3,626 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. While seeing 1,044 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #2 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.5
88,870
3,626
1,044
players
3. Outer Wilds
Similarity 50% Named Game of the Year 2019 by Giant Bomb, Polygon, Eurogamer, and The Guardian, Outer Wilds is a critically-acclaimed and award-winning open world mystery about a solar system trapped in an endless time loop. Outer Wilds is a exploration, space and mystery game developed by Mobius Digital and published by Annapurna Interactive. Released on June 18th 2020 has received 82,852 reviews of which 79,273 were positive and 3,579 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. While seeing 854 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #3 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.4
79,273
3,579
854
players
4. Little Nightmares
Similarity 59% Take on the role of Six, a lone child lost in a massive metal vessel known as the Maw, surrounded by dangerous, distorted versions of adults. You’ll need to do your best to escape in one piece or your fate will be worse than you ever dared dream. Little Nightmares is a horror, atmospheric and adventure game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on April 27th 2017 has received 109,392 reviews of which 103,708 were positive and 5,684 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. With 333 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.3
103,708
5,684
333
players
5. A Little to the Left
Similarity 50% A Little to the Left is a cozy puzzle game that has you sort, stack, and organize household items into pleasing arrangements while you keep an eye out for a mischievous cat with an inclination for chaos. Check out this playful and intuitive puzzler with 100+ satisfying messes to tidy. A Little to the Left is a puzzle, relaxing and wholesome game developed by Max Inferno and published by Secret Mode. Released on November 08th 2022 has received 13,113 reviews of which 12,074 were positive and 1,039 were negative resulting in a rating of 9.0 out of 10. With 279 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.0
12,074
1,039
279
players
6. OneShot
Similarity 58% OneShot is a surreal top down Puzzle/Adventure game with unique gameplay capabilities. You are to guide a child through a mysterious world on a mission to restore its long-dead sun. The world knows you exist. OneShot is a story rich, pixel graphics and great soundtrack game developed by Future Cat LLC and published by KOMODO. Released on December 08th 2016 has received 51,757 reviews of which 50,863 were positive and 894 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. With 222 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.6
50,863
894
222
players
7. Little Nightmares II
Similarity 56% Little Nightmares II is the second game in a series that has thrilled and captivated millions of players worldwide since 2017. Now it’s your turn to try to survive this critically acclaimed entry in the most charming horror series ever made. Little Nightmares II is a horror, adventure and singleplayer game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on February 10th 2021 has received 42,341 reviews of which 39,842 were positive and 2,499 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. With 222 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.2
39,842
2,499
222
players
8. Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair
Similarity 51% Jabberwock Island—You and your classmates were ready for fun in the sun until Monokuma returned to restart his murderous game! Trapped in a kill-or-be-killed situation, your only hope rests in solving the island’s mysteries. Danganronpa 2: Goodbye Despair is a anime, detective and visual novel game developed by Spike Chunsoft Co., Ltd. and Abstraction Games and published by Spike Chunsoft Co. and Ltd.. Released on April 18th 2016 has received 26,410 reviews of which 25,428 were positive and 982 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. With 199 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.4
25,428
982
199
players
9. CARRION
Similarity 51% CARRION is a reverse horror game in which you assume the role of an amorphous creature of unknown origins, stalking and consuming those that imprisoned you. CARRION is a villain protagonist, pixel graphics and gore game developed by Phobia Game Studio and published by Devolver Digital. Released on July 23rd 2020 has received 26,822 reviews of which 25,355 were positive and 1,467 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. With 176 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.3
25,355
1,467
176
players
10. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony
Similarity 51% A new cast of 16 characters find themselves kidnapped and imprisoned in a school. Inside, some will kill, some will die, and some will be punished. Reimagine what you thought high-stakes, fast-paced investigation was as you investigate twisted murder cases and condemn your new friends to death. Danganronpa V3: Killing Harmony is a visual novel, detective and anime game developed and published by Spike Chunsoft Co. and Ltd.. Released on September 25th 2017 has received 19,667 reviews of which 16,506 were positive and 3,161 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.2 out of 10. With 143 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
8.2
16,506
3,161
143
players
Best deals on games like Pony Island on Steam
Discover fantastic savings with the best discounts on a variety of games like Pony Island available on Steam right now, updated on May 01st 2025. Looking for even more deals? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of discounted games like Pony Island.
1. Ad Infinitum
Similarity 52% When reality is a nightmare, nightmares become real. In this psychological horror game, you fight the terrifying creatures invading your mind. Can you save your sanity? Ad Infinitum is a horror, action and psychological horror game developed by Hekate and published by Nacon. Released on September 14th 2023 has received 870 reviews of which 702 were positive and 168 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.7 out of 10. Featuring a massive 93% discount, this game currently holds the #1 spot in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.7
702
168
-93%
32.71€
2.29€
2. The Excavation of Hob's Barrow
Similarity 51% The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a folk horror narrative-driven adventure. Explore the isolated moors of rural Victorian England as you uncover the mysteries of Hob's Barrow. The answers lie in the soil... The Excavation of Hob's Barrow is a point & click, adventure and horror game developed by Cloak and Dagger Games and published by Wadjet Eye Games. Released on September 28th 2022 has received 2,387 reviews of which 2,214 were positive and 173 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.9 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 92% discount, this game is now the #2 best deal in games like Pony Island.
8.9
2,214
173
-92%
12.50€
1.00€
3. TSIOQUE
Similarity 52% TSIOQUE (pronounced: "chiock") is a dark but playful Point & Click adventure, hand-animated in meticulous, frame-by-frame 2D. Escape the clutches of an Evil Wizard and discover the secrets hidden within the spellbound castle of your ancestors. TSIOQUE is a adventure, point & click and indie game developed by OhNoo Studio and Smile and published by OhNoo Studio. Released on November 07th 2018 has received 1,799 reviews of which 1,709 were positive and 90 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.0 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 91% discount, this game is now the #3 best deal in games like Pony Island.
9.0
1,709
90
-91%
11.11€
1.00€
4. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
Similarity 53% The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is a first-person story-driven mystery. Purchase this game to get both the original and the Unreal Engine 4 remaster called The Vanishing of Ethan Carter Redux. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is a mystery, atmospheric and detective game developed and published by The Astronauts. Released on September 25th 2014 has received 8,820 reviews of which 7,794 were positive and 1,026 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.6 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #4 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.6
7,794
1,026
-90%
19.20€
1.92€
5. The Long Reach
Similarity 56% At its heart The Long Reach is an adventure game. Closer inspection also reveals it’s a thrilling horror story, flavoured with sci-fi ideology, psychological context and a skeptical view on the human psyche. The Long Reach is a adventure, action and indie game developed by Painted Black Games and published by Silver Lining Interactive. Released on March 14th 2018 has received 454 reviews of which 382 were positive and 72 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.9 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 90% discount, this title has earned the #5 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.9
382
72
-90%
14.99€
1.49€
6. Children of Silentown
Similarity 55% Children of Silentown is a dark adventure game that tells the story of Lucy, a girl growing up in a village deep in a forest inhabited by monsters. People disappearing is nothing uncommon here, but this time, Lucy is old enough to investigate on her own. Or so she thinks. Children of Silentown is a atmospheric, adventure and point & click game developed by Elf Games and Luna2 Studio and published by Daedalic Entertainment. Released on January 11th 2023 has received 1,275 reviews of which 1,110 were positive and 165 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.3 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 89% discount, this title has earned the #6 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.3
1,110
165
-89%
19.36€
2.13€
7. Conarium
Similarity 50% Conarium is a chilling Lovecraftian game, which follows a gripping story involving four scientists and their endeavor to challenge what we normally consider to be the ‘absolute’ limits of nature. Inspired by H.P. Lovecraft’s novella "At the Mountains of Madness", but largely set after the original story. Conarium is a adventure, lovecraftian and horror game developed by Stormling Studios and published by Iceberg Interactive. Released on June 06th 2017 has received 2,142 reviews of which 1,654 were positive and 488 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.5 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 89% discount, this title has earned the #7 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.5
1,654
488
-89%
20.36€
2.24€
8. Horror Story: Hallowseed
Similarity 59% Horror Story: Hallowseed is a story-driven psychological horror game. An obscure event causes two of your friends to disappear while you were camping in the woods. Left alone and stranded in an unknown place, you need to seek the answers about what happened, face the horror and find your friends. Horror Story: Hallowseed is a horror, psychological horror and atmospheric game developed by Jeff Winner and published by Fulqrum Publishing. Released on October 28th 2021 has received 325 reviews of which 219 were positive and 106 were negative resulting in a rating of 6.4 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 89% discount, this title has earned the #8 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
6.4
219
106
-89%
19.73€
2.17€
9. 2Dark
Similarity 58% 2Dark is a stealth adventure game developed by Frédérick Raynal, the pioneer of survival horror games and creator of Alone in the Dark®. Make your way through the lairs of psychopaths, unravel intrigue where madness mingles with horror, and, above all, save the kids! 2Dark is a indie, horror and stealth game developed by Gloomywood and published by Nacon. Released on March 10th 2017 has received 783 reviews of which 607 were positive and 176 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.4 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 87% discount, this title has earned the #9 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.4
607
176
-87%
25.08€
3.26€
10. Gods Will Be Watching
Similarity 60% Gods Will Be Watching is a minimalistic “point and click thriller” centered on despair, commitment, and sacrifice as players face intriguing puzzles and tough decisions that will affect their entire crew’s wellbeing. Gods Will Be Watching is a indie, pixel graphics and point & click game developed by Deconstructeam and published by Devolver Digital. Released on July 24th 2014 has received 2,871 reviews of which 2,024 were positive and 847 were negative resulting in a rating of 6.9 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 87% discount, this title has earned the #10 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
6.9
2,024
847
-87%
9.62€
1.25€
Free games like Pony Island on Steam
Check out this fantastic list of free-to-play games like Pony Island you can enjoy on Steam right now, updated on May 01st 2025. Looking for even more free titles? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of free to play games like Pony Island.
1. Cube Escape: Paradox
Similarity 60% The tenth Cube Escape follows the story of detective Dale Vandermeer who finds himself trapped in two different universes and needs to escape. Cube Escape: Paradox will be released together with the accompanying Paradox: A Rusty Lake Film. Cube Escape: Paradox is a puzzle, free to play and psychological horror game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on September 20th 2018 has received 10,317 reviews of which 10,035 were positive and 282 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #1 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
10,035
282
75
players
2. Indigo Park: Chapter 1
Similarity 55% Explore the abandoned childhood wonder of Indigo Park! Guided by Rambley the Raccoon, help restore power to the destroyed amusement park while you run from the reason it shut down. Indigo Park: Chapter 1 is a horror, free to play and first-person game developed and published by UniqueGeese. Released on May 18th 2024 has received 20,666 reviews of which 19,744 were positive and 922 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. The game currently holds the #2 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.3
19,744
922
42
players
3. Samsara Room
Similarity 52% You woke up in a mysterious room you have never seen before. Can you find another way out? Samsara Room is a remake of the praised predecessor of the Rusty Lake & Cube Escape series. Samsara Room is a indie, adventure and puzzle game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on April 29th 2020 has received 9,038 reviews of which 8,797 were positive and 241 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #3 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
8,797
241
41
players
4. Yume Nikki
Similarity 57% This is a game in which you traverse the extremely dark world inside a dream. Yume Nikki is a indie, free to play and rpgmaker game developed by kikiyama and published by PLAYISM. Released on January 09th 2018 has received 8,475 reviews of which 7,968 were positive and 507 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.1 out of 10. The game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.1
7,968
507
28
players
5. Paper Lily - Chapter 1
Similarity 51% Paper Lily is an RPG horror game in which you can solve puzzles in different ways. Explore a hidden world, meet strange characters, and guide Lacie as she attempts to find answers about her unusual condition. Paper Lily - Chapter 1 is a pixel graphics, psychological horror and anime game developed and published by Leef 6010. Released on January 26th 2024 has received 6,254 reviews of which 6,198 were positive and 56 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.6
6,198
56
26
players
6. Outcore: Desktop Adventure
Similarity 54% All you wanted was a nice game. But now you find yourself opening Windows apps like Paint & Notepad to solve puzzles, and searching for files on your computers that you didn't put there... Who is she? Why did she appear on your desktop? Let's dive into her memories and find out. Outcore: Desktop Adventure is a adventure, psychological horror and free to play game developed and published by Doctor Shinobi. Released on September 26th 2022 has received 14,933 reviews of which 14,532 were positive and 401 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. The game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.5
14,532
401
19
players
7. Nightmare House: The Original Mod
Similarity 54% Wake up, it’s time for the real nightmare to begin. Make your way through a terrorizing house, uncover the secrets of a haunted hospital, fight through hordes of the undead, and try to escape Nightmare House. Nightmare House: The Original Mod is a free to play, horror and action-adventure game developed and published by We Create Stuff. Released on November 14th 2024 has received 1,295 reviews of which 1,257 were positive and 38 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. The game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.2
1,257
38
13
players
8. 异化之恶〇Abnormal Treatment
Similarity 60% Strange events occur at a sanatorium for those with unusual abilities. Follow clues, solve puzzles, and uncover the truth. What will be released when all secrets are revealed? Goodness? Or… pure ”EVIL”? 异化之恶〇Abnormal Treatment is a rpgmaker, rpg and cute game developed by Eternal Dream and published by Eternal Dream and 迷糊的安安. Released on August 02nd 2019 has received 3,501 reviews of which 3,415 were positive and 86 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
3,415
86
10
players
9. At Home Alone Final
Similarity 56% A casual healing rpg that takes players on a journey around the house from the perspective of a young girl, what does she do when she's home alone? What strange things will you come across in the process, and while exploring, perhaps... What other strange secrets might you discover? At Home Alone Final is a free to play, rpg and horror game developed by 阿正不经 and published by 0Cube. Released on December 31st 2021 has received 7,159 reviews of which 6,966 were positive and 193 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
6,966
193
8
players
10. There Is No Game: Jam Edition 2015
Similarity 51% A little game that’s not a game, winner of an old game jam that nobody’s ever heard of. So DON'T INSTALL IT! There Is No Game: Jam Edition 2015 is a indie, free to play and casual game developed and published by Draw Me A Pixel. Released on March 18th 2020 has received 6,972 reviews of which 6,756 were positive and 216 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
6,756
216
7
players