Games like Pony Island on Steam
For those who prefer not to search, lists of the most played, top deals and best free games like Pony Island are available at the bottom of the page.
Filters & Lists
DISTRAINT: Deluxe Edition
DISTRAINT is a 2D psychological horror adventure game for PC. In order to secure a partnership in a famous company, Price seizes the property of an elderly woman. In that very moment, he finds out the price of his humanity.
4D Minesweeper
4D Minesweeper brings the classic mechanics of Minesweeper into the fourth dimension and adds some new features to it.
SORE
Mystical puzzle quest game in a gloomy minimalism style will tell you a story of a person who's got himself into a camera, and from which there is no way out it seems. Experimental gameplay diluted with a pinch of a philosophy, that's what SORE is.
Stephen's Sausage Roll
A simple 3d puzzle game.
Welcome to the Game
Welcome to the Game is a creepy horror/puzzle game that takes you into the world of the Deep Web. Explore the Deep Web with the sole purpose of trying to find a Red Room, an online service / website that allows you to see and participate in interactive torture and murder.
The Death | Thần Trùng
The Death | Thần Trùng is a Viet Nam psychological horror adventure game made by three Vietnamese people from a tiny indie studio. The game takes place in Hanoi city in 2022.
FAITH: The Unholy Trinity
What you are about to do has not been approved by the Vatican. As a young priest, struggle against demons, insane cultists, and your own weakening faith in this pixel horror game inspired by the era of classic 8-bit gaming and the "Satanic Scare" of the 1980s.
Silence of the Sleep
You play as a man called Jacob Reeves. A man who has lost his reason to live. He throws himself into a blackness to end his misery, but instead of it being the end he wakes up without a memory of his life before.
Sally Face - Episode One
Delve into a dark adventure following the boy with a prosthetic face and a tragic past. Unravel the sinister mysteries of Sally's world to find the truth that lies hidden beneath the shadows.
Please, Don’t Touch Anything
A brain-racking game about bathroom breaks, screwdrivers and nuclear explosions.
I hate this game
I hate this game is a logic game, where gameplay changes every level. Solve crazy puzzles and use forgotten functions of your PC! Be attentive, interact with everything that you see on the screen.
I'm on Observation Duty
As an employee of a mysterious organization your job is to monitor live surveillance camera footage and spot anomalies using your sharp eyes and good memory. Can you survive the entire night shift or will you succumb into paranoia?
Detention
Detention is an atmospheric horror game set in 1960s Taiwan under martial law. Incorporated religious elements based in Taiwanese/Chinese culture and mythology, the game provided players with unique graphics and gaming experience.
The Room Syndrome
Explore the mysterious room by traversing time, while you watch a man succumb to the room syndrome.
FEZ
Gomez is a 2D creature living in a 2D world. Or is he? When the existence of a mysterious 3rd dimension is revealed to him, Gomez is sent out on a journey that will take him to the very end of time and space. Use your ability to navigate 3D structures from 4 distinct classic 2D perspectives.
My Big Sister
My name is Luzia...and this story isn't about me, it’s about my sister. Do you still wish to hear it?
The Bad Kids
As an adaptation of the popular suspecse TV series, Cat's Cradle, this game combines investigation, solving puzzles and reasoning with original stories, which can build a more Immersive experience. Game will build new stories based on original setting and focus on the inner world of the character.
Layers of Fear 2 (2019)
Layers of Fear 2 is a first-person psychological horror game with an emphasis on exploration and story. Players control a Hollywood actor who heeds the call of an enigmatic director to take on the lead role in a film shot aboard an ocean liner. Beware, for all may not truly be what it seems.
Most played games like Pony Island on Steam
Take a look at the top games like Pony Island that are currently attracting the largest player bases on the Steam platform, as of June 15th 2025.
1. Poppy Playtime
Similarity 52% You must stay alive in this horror/puzzle adventure. Try to survive the vengeful toys waiting for you in the abandoned toy factory. Use your GrabPack to hack electrical circuits or nab anything from afar. Explore the mysterious facility... and don't get caught. Poppy Playtime is a horror, free to play and singleplayer game developed and published by Mob Entertainment. Released on October 12th 2021 has received 98,914 reviews of which 84,113 were positive and 14,801 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.4 out of 10. The game has hit the top spot as the #1 most played game like Pony Island, thanks to its 749 peak concurrent players over the last day.
8.4
84,113
14,801
749
players
2. OMORI
Similarity 57% Explore a strange world full of colorful friends and foes. When the time comes, the path you’ve chosen will determine your fate... and perhaps the fate of others as well. OMORI is a psychological horror, story rich and pixel graphics game developed and published by OMOCAT and LLC. Released on December 25th 2020 has received 80,237 reviews of which 78,023 were positive and 2,214 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. While seeing 546 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #2 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.6
78,023
2,214
546
players
3. Little Nightmares
Similarity 46% Take on the role of Six, a lone child lost in a massive metal vessel known as the Maw, surrounded by dangerous, distorted versions of adults. You’ll need to do your best to escape in one piece or your fate will be worse than you ever dared dream. Little Nightmares is a horror, atmospheric and adventure game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on April 27th 2017 has received 110,196 reviews of which 104,472 were positive and 5,724 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.3 out of 10. While seeing 440 players online at once in the last 24 hours, this game is currently ranked #3 among games like Pony Island based on player count.
9.3
104,472
5,724
440
players
4. Little Nightmares II
Similarity 49% Little Nightmares II is the second game in a series that has thrilled and captivated millions of players worldwide since 2017. Now it’s your turn to try to survive this critically acclaimed entry in the most charming horror series ever made. Little Nightmares II is a horror, adventure and singleplayer game developed by Tarsier Studios and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. Released on February 10th 2021 has received 43,042 reviews of which 40,494 were positive and 2,548 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. With 298 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.2
40,494
2,548
298
players
5. Baba Is You
Similarity 57% Baba Is You is a puzzle game where the rules you have to follow are present as blocks you can interact with. By manipulating them, you can change how the game works, repurpose things you find in the levels and cause surprising interactions! Baba Is You is a puzzle, indie and difficult game developed and published by Hempuli Oy. Released on March 13th 2019 has received 21,921 reviews of which 21,441 were positive and 480 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. With 232 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.6
21,441
480
232
players
6. Sally Face - Episode One
Similarity 61% Delve into a dark adventure following the boy with a prosthetic face and a tragic past. Unravel the sinister mysteries of Sally's world to find the truth that lies hidden beneath the shadows. Sally Face - Episode One is a story rich, psychological horror and indie game developed and published by Portable Moose. Released on December 14th 2016 has received 22,561 reviews of which 21,939 were positive and 622 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. With 129 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.5
21,939
622
129
players
7. CrossCode
Similarity 46% A retro-inspired 2D Action RPG set in the distant future. CrossCode combines 16-bit SNES-style graphics with butter-smooth physics, a fast-paced combat system, and engaging puzzle mechanics, served with a gripping sci-fi story. CrossCode is a action rpg, pixel graphics and rpg game developed by Radical Fish Games and published by Deck13, WhisperGames, DANGEN Entertainment and Mayflower Entertainment. Released on September 20th 2018 has received 16,866 reviews of which 15,699 were positive and 1,167 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.1 out of 10. With 125 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.1
15,699
1,167
125
players
8. Chants of Sennaar
Similarity 44% In this award-winning puzzle adventure game, play as the Traveler on a quest to reunite the Peoples of the Tower. Observe, listen, and decipher ancient languages in a fascinating universe inspired by the Myth of Babel. Chants of Sennaar is a puzzle, adventure and singleplayer game developed by Rundisc and published by Focus Entertainment. Released on September 05th 2023 has received 22,453 reviews of which 22,075 were positive and 378 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. With 119 concurrent players in the last 24 hours, the game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.6
22,075
378
119
players
9. OneShot
Similarity 53% OneShot is a surreal top down Puzzle/Adventure game with unique gameplay capabilities. You are to guide a child through a mysterious world on a mission to restore its long-dead sun. The world knows you exist. OneShot is a story rich, pixel graphics and indie game developed by Future Cat LLC and published by KOMODO. Released on December 08th 2016 has received 53,704 reviews of which 52,785 were positive and 919 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.7 out of 10. The game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.7
52,785
919
96
players
10. Cube Escape: Paradox
Similarity 52% The tenth Cube Escape follows the story of detective Dale Vandermeer who finds himself trapped in two different universes and needs to escape. Cube Escape: Paradox will be released together with the accompanying Paradox: A Rusty Lake Film. Cube Escape: Paradox is a puzzle, free to play and psychological horror game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on September 20th 2018 has received 10,554 reviews of which 10,264 were positive and 290 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played games like Pony Island.
9.4
10,264
290
89
players
Best deals on games like Pony Island on Steam
Discover fantastic savings with the best discounts on a variety of games like Pony Island available on Steam right now, updated on June 15th 2025. Looking for even more deals? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of discounted games like Pony Island.
1. In Sound Mind
Similarity 55% In Sound Mind is an imaginative first-person psychological horror with frenetic puzzles, unique boss fights, and original music by The Living Tombstone. Journey within the inner workings of the one place you can’t seem to escape—your own mind. In Sound Mind is a horror, psychological horror and story rich game developed by We Create Stuff and published by Maximum Entertainment. Released on September 28th 2021 has received 5,812 reviews of which 5,535 were positive and 277 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. Featuring a massive 99% discount, this game currently holds the #1 spot in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.2
5,535
277
-99%
29.99€
0.52€
2. Tormented Souls
Similarity 45% Classic survival horror is back! Inspired by the original Resident Evil and Alone in the Dark series, Tormented Souls modernises with a fresh twist on the fixed perspective adventure - as Caroline Walker investigates the mysterious disappearance of twin girls in a terrifying mansion-turned-hospital. Tormented Souls is a survival horror, horror and puzzle game developed by Dual Effect and Abstract Digital and published by PQube. Released on August 26th 2021 has received 6,089 reviews of which 5,544 were positive and 545 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.8 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 98% discount, this game is now the #2 best deal in games like Pony Island.
8.8
5,544
545
-98%
19.99€
0.45€
3. She Remembered Caterpillars
Similarity 48% A fungipunk fantasy about love, loss, and holding on, told in the format of a color-based puzzle game. A tale as the bond between parent and child, this lush and bewildering title will have players testing their wits against a variety of challenges, all beautiful and very strange. She Remembered Caterpillars is a puzzle, indie and hand-drawn game developed by jumpsuit entertainment UG (haftungsbeschränkt) and published by Ysbryd Games and WhisperGames. Released on January 17th 2017 has received 524 reviews of which 497 were positive and 27 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.8 out of 10. Thanks to its incredible 98% discount, this game is now the #3 best deal in games like Pony Island.
8.8
497
27
-98%
11.99€
0.31€
4. Stacking
Similarity 44% Embark on an adventure to rescue Charlie’s family from the nefarious industrialist known only as the 'Baron.' Stacking is a adventure, puzzle and indie game developed and published by Double Fine Productions. Released on March 06th 2012 has received 1,780 reviews of which 1,587 were positive and 193 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.5 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 98% discount, this title has earned the #4 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.5
1,587
193
-98%
9.99€
0.26€
5. Fobia - St. Dinfna Hotel
Similarity 43% Explore a decadent hotel across different timelines and uncover the dark history of a fanatical cult and your role in their plans. Fobia - St. Dinfna Hotel is a indie, survival horror and violent game developed by Pulsatrix Studios and published by Maximum Entertainment. Released on June 28th 2022 has received 1,982 reviews of which 1,686 were positive and 296 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.2 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 98% discount, this title has earned the #5 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
8.2
1,686
296
-98%
24.99€
0.62€
6. 2Dark
Similarity 47% 2Dark is a stealth adventure game developed by Frédérick Raynal, the pioneer of survival horror games and creator of Alone in the Dark®. Make your way through the lairs of psychopaths, unravel intrigue where madness mingles with horror, and, above all, save the kids! 2Dark is a indie, horror and stealth game developed by Gloomywood and published by Nacon. Released on March 10th 2017 has received 797 reviews of which 617 were positive and 180 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.4 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 98% discount, this title has earned the #6 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.4
617
180
-98%
24.99€
0.70€
7. Hue
Similarity 45% Hue is a vibrant, award-winning puzzle-adventure, where you alter the world by changing its background colour. Hue is a indie, puzzle and adventure game developed by Fiddlesticks Games and published by Curve Games. Released on August 30th 2016 has received 10,524 reviews of which 9,736 were positive and 788 were negative resulting in a rating of 9.0 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 97% discount, this title has earned the #7 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.0
9,736
788
-97%
14.99€
0.49€
8. Sorry, James
Similarity 45% JAMES_GARNER zEiaQe@z1l3 Sorry, James is a indie, puzzle and story rich game developed by Konstructors and published by Hook Games, GrabTheGames and WhisperGames. Released on November 10th 2017 has received 844 reviews of which 670 were positive and 174 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.6 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 97% discount, this title has earned the #8 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
7.6
670
174
-97%
6.89€
0.25€
9. Lost in Play
Similarity 44% Solve puzzles, riddles, and embark on an exciting journey of discovery! Join Toto and Gal as they explore dreamscapes and befriend magical creatures. Lost in their imagination, the brother and sister must stick together and solve puzzles to find their way home. Lost in Play is a puzzle, point & click and indie game developed by Happy Juice Games and published by Joystick Ventures. Released on August 10th 2022 has received 7,049 reviews of which 6,924 were positive and 125 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.5 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 96% discount, this title has earned the #9 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.5
6,924
125
-96%
19.99€
0.94€
10. In Sound Mind
Similarity 55% In Sound Mind is an imaginative first-person psychological horror with frenetic puzzles, unique boss fights, and original music by The Living Tombstone. Journey within the inner workings of the one place you can’t seem to escape—your own mind. In Sound Mind is a game developed and published by . Released on September 28th 2021 has received 5,812 reviews of which 5,535 were positive and 277 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.2 out of 10. Currently offered at a significant 99% discount, this title has earned the #10 position in the best deals for games like Pony Island.
9.2
5,535
277
-99%
29.99€
0.52€
Free games like Pony Island on Steam
Check out this fantastic list of free-to-play games like Pony Island you can enjoy on Steam right now, updated on June 15th 2025. Looking for even more free titles? Use the search filters to explore a wider range of free to play games like Pony Island.
1. Poppy Playtime
Similarity 52% You must stay alive in this horror/puzzle adventure. Try to survive the vengeful toys waiting for you in the abandoned toy factory. Use your GrabPack to hack electrical circuits or nab anything from afar. Explore the mysterious facility... and don't get caught. Poppy Playtime is a horror, free to play and singleplayer game developed and published by Mob Entertainment. Released on October 12th 2021 has received 98,914 reviews of which 84,113 were positive and 14,801 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.4 out of 10. With 749 active players enjoying it for free, this strategy game has reached the #1 spot among the top free games like Pony Island.
8.4
84,113
14,801
749
players
2. Cube Escape: Paradox
Similarity 52% The tenth Cube Escape follows the story of detective Dale Vandermeer who finds himself trapped in two different universes and needs to escape. Cube Escape: Paradox will be released together with the accompanying Paradox: A Rusty Lake Film. Cube Escape: Paradox is a puzzle, free to play and psychological horror game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on September 20th 2018 has received 10,554 reviews of which 10,264 were positive and 290 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #2 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
10,264
290
89
players
3. Helltaker
Similarity 45% Helltaker is a short game about sharply dressed demon girls. Helltaker is a free to play, cute and demons game developed and published by vanripper. Released on May 11th 2020 has received 124,918 reviews of which 122,115 were positive and 2,803 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game currently holds the #3 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.6
122,115
2,803
71
players
4. Garten of Banban 0
Similarity 48% Explore the origins of the mysterious Banban’s Kindergarten. Survive the dark past of the establishment. Try to make some friends. Uncover the truth behind the place, and who you are… Garten of Banban 0 is a horror, singleplayer and first-person game developed and published by Euphoric Brothers. Released on February 21st 2025 has received 2,733 reviews of which 1,973 were positive and 760 were negative resulting in a rating of 7.0 out of 10. The game currently holds the #4 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
7.0
1,973
760
57
players
5. Yume Nikki
Similarity 46% This is a game in which you traverse the extremely dark world inside a dream. Yume Nikki is a indie, free to play and rpgmaker game developed by kikiyama and published by PLAYISM. Released on January 09th 2018 has received 8,629 reviews of which 8,120 were positive and 509 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.1 out of 10. The game currently holds the #5 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.1
8,120
509
44
players
6. Paper Lily - Chapter 1
Similarity 44% Paper Lily is an RPG horror game in which you can solve puzzles in different ways. Explore a hidden world, meet strange characters, and guide Lacie as she attempts to find answers about her unusual condition. Paper Lily - Chapter 1 is a pixel graphics, psychological horror and story rich game developed and published by Leef 6010. Released on January 26th 2024 has received 6,621 reviews of which 6,562 were positive and 59 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.6 out of 10. The game currently holds the #6 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.6
6,562
59
33
players
7. Samsara Room
Similarity 48% You woke up in a mysterious room you have never seen before. Can you find another way out? Samsara Room is a remake of the praised predecessor of the Rusty Lake & Cube Escape series. Samsara Room is a indie, adventure and puzzle game developed and published by Rusty Lake. Released on April 29th 2020 has received 9,202 reviews of which 8,956 were positive and 246 were negative resulting in an impressive rating of 9.4 out of 10. The game currently holds the #7 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
9.4
8,956
246
16
players
8. Zen of Sudoku
Similarity 46% From the creators of Natural Selection comes Zen of Sudoku, a relaxing, easy to play version of Sudoku for your PC.Relax with hand-painted Japanese-styled backgrounds, no timer and lush natural soundscapes.Stimulates your brain to keep it healthy and alert. Zen of Sudoku is a casual, indie and puzzle game developed and published by Unknown Worlds Entertainment. Released on December 14th 2006 has received 338 reviews of which 303 were positive and 35 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.3 out of 10. The game currently holds the #8 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
8.3
303
35
6
players
9. Mr. Hopp's Playhouse
Similarity 47% Every kid has that one toy that scares them, imagine if it came to life. You play as Ruby, a young girl who has a fear of her handmade toy called Mr. Hopp. Things take a dark turn when Ruby sees that Mr. Hopp, who usually sits motionless in the corner of her room, is gone. Mr. Hopp's Playhouse is a horror, free to play and indie game developed and published by Moonbit. Released on November 15th 2019 has received 1,670 reviews of which 1,562 were positive and 108 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.9 out of 10. The game currently holds the #9 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
8.9
1,562
108
5
players
10. Sigils of Elohim
Similarity 44% Sigils of Elohim is a free mini-game prelude to Croteam’s upcoming first-person puzzler The Talos Principle that challenges players to solve dozens of challenging sigil puzzles under the watchful eye of Elohim. Sigils of Elohim is a free to play, puzzle and casual game developed by Croteam and published by Devolver Digital. Released on October 13th 2014 has received 1,164 reviews of which 1,063 were positive and 101 were negative resulting in a rating of 8.6 out of 10. The game currently holds the #10 spot among the most played free games like Pony Island.
8.6
1,063
101
5
players